Antonio Galloni – Robert Parker about Tuscany 2009 and 2010
Tuscany 2009 and 2010: A World of Opposites
These are interesting times in Tuscany. There is no doubt the region is in the midst of a profound stylistic evolution. A growing number of estates are moving in the direction of more natural viticulture. In the cellar, new oak is down and the use of neutral vessels is up. Cement, once virtually forgotten, is making a huge comeback. As it turns out, the makers of cement tanks and vats are now taking as long as six months to fill orders, something that was unheard of up until very recently. In Chianti, Sangiovese continues to gain favor, while the use of international grapes in Tuscany’s most famous wine has decreased. Readers will find three very different vintages in the market; the cool, powerful 2010s, the radiant 2009s and the irregular 2008s. As always, Italy’s byzantine regulations can be intimidating for those who don’t yet feel comfortable with the wines. Readers who take the time to get to know the producers in this article will be rewarded with a number of stunning bottles at all price points. I tasted the majority of the wines in this report during a week I spent in Tuscany in April 2012, followed by tastings in New York shortly thereafter.
Vintage 2009 Overview
The 2009s are wines of contrasts. The winter and spring were on the cool and damp side in most parts of Tuscany. In some spots flowering got off to an early start, as temperatures were higher than normal in May. The summer was very hot, culminating with an intense heat wave that arrived in mid-August. This is the time when evening temperatures typically begin to moderate as the summer winds down and fall arrives. Not in 2009. The worst of the heat lasted over a week. I have a vivid recollection of that time because I was on vacation in Tuscany with my family. It was hot, hot, hot. The most adversely affected area was Maremma, where I came across a number of wines that had their personalities baked out by the heat. Chianti Classico, which is generally cooler, was spared the worst of the heat. In some places, the warmth actually helped fill out some of the wines. A number of producers did not bottle their top wines in 2009, and many of those who did were very severe in their selection of what made it into bottle.
It is hard to make a broad generalization about the 2009s given the sheer size of Tuscany, but in general it can be said that the wines tend to have medium-bodied structures of cooler vintages, but the radiant, ripe fruit typical of warmer years. I don’t expect this to be a vintage to cellar over the long term, but it should be a useful crop of wines to drink while the 2006s, 2007s and 2008s come around. Overall, I find much less personality in the 2009s than I do in the surrounding vintages, although, as always, I prefer to choose producer first and vintage second.
Vintage 2010 Overview
In Chianti Classico, 2010 is shaping up to be a great vintage, perhaps one of the greatest. It was a cold year, with an irregular flowering that lowered yields, and a very late harvest. The wines possess stunning depth, well-delineated aromatics and massive structure. If I had to draw comparisons with recent years, I would say the 2010s have the aromatics of 2004, the fruit density of 2007 and the structure of 2006. Sounds pretty appealing, doesn’t it? Readers can get a sense of the year by tasting the Chiantis that are entering the market over the next few months. And it’s not just the Chiantis from the Classico zone that are terrific, there are plenty of wines from the broader Chianti zone that are also compelling, especially because they can be had for a fraction of the price. I am equally enthusiastic about the wines of Montalcino, as I described in Issue 200. So far, I have tasted less from Maremma, but what I have seen is promising as well.
—Antonio Galloni
Piaggia Poggio de’ Colli IGT Toscana Cabernet Franc 2010 94 points
Piaggia Poggio de’ Colli IGt Toscana Cabernet Franc 2009 93 points
Piaggia Carmignano Riserva 2008 93 points
Piaggia Carmignano Riserva 2009 92+ points
Piaggia Carmignano Il Sasso 2009 92 points
Moris Farms Morellino di Scansano Riserva 2009 92 points
Moris Farms Monteregio di Massa Marittima 2009 90 points
Moris Farms Morellino di Scansano 2011 89 points
Moris Farms Vermentino IGT Toscana 2011 87
Fattoria di Piazzano Colorino 2010 IGT Toscana 91 points
Fattoria di Piazzano Sangiovese 2008 IGT Toscana 89 points
Fattoria di Piazzano Syrah 2009 IGt Toscana 88 points
Fattoria di Piazzano Chianti 2011 86 points
Sassotondo Sovana Superiore 2008 92 points
Sassotondo San Lorenzo IGT Maremma Toscana Ciliegiolo 2008 90 points
Sassotondo Ciliegiolo IGT Maremma Toscana 2011 89 points
Sassotondo Tuforosso IGT Maremma Toscana 2011 88 points
Giacomo Mori Chianti Castelrotto Riserva 2009 89 points
Giacomo Mori Chianti 2010 89 points
Giacomo Mori Vinsanto del Chianti 2006 90 points